18 March 2012

hunger games trilogy, my review - contains spoilers

since the hunger games was the talk of the town [internet], i decided to give it a chance.   i don't feel that i have enough to say about each book to write three separate reviews, so i'm lumping them all together.

 the books are very well written, move quickly and are fairly short. (i read each one in a day.)  i think i read somewhere that they are targeted for teens, and they certainly have a tame feel to the blood & gore as well as the relationship angle; i like this about them.

my favorite was the first book.  written with a strong love story theme, it promised that the sequels would be the same.  this book is of course about the hunger games, and katniss' journey to becoming a 'victor.'  the cliff hanger ending gives enough closure to make me happy (it annoys me when stories don't wrap up in the course of the novel), but enough loose ends that i really wanted to read the second one immediately.  had this not been designed as a trilogy, i think that it would have been more entertaining for katniss to die and cato and foxface battle it out.

the second book has much less of a romantic theme and takes on a very political feel.  while the story is easy to follow, it never has any peace.  there is perpetually an uneasy feeling (the author was very good at conveying emotions.)  i was pretty tired by the end of this one, but stayed up well past bed time to finish it and considered starting the third in the wee hours of the morning.

the third book was my least favorite.  even though there is a conclusion, i was not convinced that katniss was truly happy, nor that peeta was able to come back to himself.  i did not like that the author made gale into an antagonist so that katniss could end up with peeta. oh, and the fact that she never finished up with those two refugees from 8 in the woods other than "oh, i guess they died in the forest" really annoyed me too. i did not feel near the degree of sorrow when prim died that i did when rue died.  it seemed like prim's death was used solely as a catalyst and could have been avoided. i would have preferred and ending where gale was the one to perish - giving her an excuse to kill coin and leaving katniss fully open for a relationship with peeta, plus a happy ending for her family. 

i enjoyed the series as a whole, but will likely never read them again (but you'll probably catch me in the theater to see them.)  if you can borrow them instead of purchasing them, i would highly recommend it.

later days

No comments:

Post a Comment